There is also another significant difference between the two methods besides the time factor. Tumbling and polishing will mechanically remove the tarnish so some silver is lost. Harsh chemical removal solutions also do the same thing. But using the baking soda method will preserve the silver because the silver sulfide layer is simply converted back to silver.
Sulfur is not the only compound that readily reacts with silver. This easy method gets the black silver sulfide to react with the aluminum so that the sulfur atoms transfer over to it as shown in this chemical equation :
So how well does it work?
I tried using the baking soda method to clean this badly tarnished pair of ear wires. This pair couldn't be any worse!
What I used :
- 1 cup of water heated in a microwave oven on high for 1 1/2 minutes
- 1 tablespoon of baking soda
- A small glass bowl lined with aluminum foil at the bottom
The hot water helps dissolve the baking soda faster and also speeds up the reaction.
I added the baking soda and mixed until it was dissolved.
I dropped in the ear wires and made sure they were in contact with the aluminum as much as possible. The process is actually an electrochemical reaction whereby a small electric current occurs between the silver and the aluminum - like how batteries work. This is why the ear wires need to be in contact with the foil. I also turned over the ear wires part way through to "do" the other side.
Bubbles formed as the chemical reaction began.
A lightly tarnished pair of ear wires I previously cleaned took about 5-10 minutes. This pair though was so badly tarnished 15 minutes was not enough. I repeated the cleaning with a fresh solution for another 10 minutes.
As you can see, most of the tarnish is gone. The ear wires though were not as shiny as they could be at close magnification. You can see smudges around the curved portions of the ear wires.
I could have repeated the process yet again but I just used my polishing cloth to finish up.
Verdict : It is a quick and easy method especially if the pieces were not too badly tarnished. The process is ideal for silver plated pieces which might not survive tumbling. But for really shiny silver pieces, it's hard to beat tumbling.
Before You Go:
- Tips on How to Use Boiled Eggs for Metal Oxidation
- 8 Ways to Patinate Jewelry
- How to Clean off Green Gunk with Common Kitchen Items
- What to do about Copper Turning Skin Green
Original Post by THE BEADING GEM
Jewelry Making Tips - Jewelry Business Tips